Built in 1840, this Colonial with strong Gothic Revival influence offers a level of character that simply cannot be replicated. There is a quiet confidence here, an authenticity shaped by nearly two centuries of history. Original features include a brick fireplace with beehive oven, hand-hewn beams, a hidden vertical sliding stair door, pointed-arch wall niches, and Gothic Revival moulding throughout, bringing depth and personality to the main house. A clawfoot tub with circular shower curtain, custom-built antique vanity, and a high tank toilet with pull chain preserve the integrity of an era that was both bold and sophisticated. A large sunroom connects to the kitchen with a pass-through window, allowing light to pour in from an entire wall of sliders. Step onto the balcony to watch the water glisten, or settle in beside the woodstove during a snowstorm. This space works effortlessly year round. With 450 feet of frontage along Lake Todd in the no-wake zone, the property offers a calm, protected waterfront environment ideal for swimming, paddling, and enjoying local wildlife, along with your own private beach. Beyond the main residence, the property offers uncommon versatility. Unit two, a converted carriage house, includes a convenient mudroom, a large living room with hardwood floors, a private balcony, and a galley kitchen. Upstairs, there is a large bedroom, a bonus room perfect for an at home office, and a bathroom with a stand up shower. Unit three features an open concept kitchen connected to a large living room with a wood stove, along with one upstairs bedroom and bathroom. Both units are fully separate, offering strong income potential or multigenerational living while maintaining privacy. A property that brings together historic character, waterfront living, and established rental revenue, all while maintaining privacy for the primary home. Please view property's 3D tour in additional links, plus drone video of property and grounds.